The State Bar of California
  • Log in
  • News
  • Forms
  • Contact
About Us:
  • Our Mission
  • |
  • Who We Are
  • |
  • News
  • |
  • Careers
  • |
  • Business Opportunities
  • Public
    • Need Legal Help
      • Look Up a Lawyer
      • Using a Certified Lawyer Referral Service
        • Certified Lawyer Referral Services Directory
          • LRS FAQs for Consumers
          • File a Complaint about an LRS
          • How to Become a Certified LRS
      • Free Legal Help
    • Complaints & Claims
      • How to File a Complaint
        • Before You File
        • Why File a Complaint
        • Attorney Complaint
        • After You File
        • Después de presentar una queja
        • Nonattorney Complaint
        • Discipline Referral
      • Unauthorized Practice of Law Complaint
        • After You File
        • Después de presentar una queja por práctica no autorizada
      • Fee Disputes
        • FAQ
      • Client Security Fund
        • Client Security Fund Application Process
        • Application Instructions
      • Lawyer Referral Service Complaints
        • Certified Lawyer Referral Service Complaints
        • Uncertified Lawyer Referral Service Complaints
      • FAQ
    • Free Legal Information
      • Before Selecting an Attorney
        • Finding the Right Lawyer
        • What a Certified Lawyer Referral Service Can Do for You
        • Your Initial Consultation
      • Working with an Attorney
        • What to Expect from Your Attorney
        • How to Work with Your Lawyer
        • What to Expect Regarding Fees and Billing
        • How to Avoid Problems
      • Resolving Problems
        • Problem with a Lawyer
        • Lawyer Fee Dispute
          • Lawyer Fee Dispute FAQ
        • Client Security Fund
      • Unauthorized Practice of Law
        • Avoiding Fraud by Immigration Consultants
        • Práctica no autorizada de la abogacía
        • Evite el fraude por parte de los consultores de inmigración
      • For Immigrants
        • Buscando ayuda con asuntos de inmigración
        • Immigration Legal Services Providers
        • Proveedores de servicios legales de inmigración
      • Legal Help After a Disaster
      • For Veterans & Service Members
      • Legal Services Fraud Alert for Homeowners
        • Alerta a Propietarios Referente al Fraude de Servicios Legales
      • Legal Services Fraud Alert for Renters
        • Alerta a Arrendatarios Referente al Fraude de Servicios Legales
      • Legal Guide Pamphlets
      • FAQ
    • Discipline
      • Attorney Discipline
      • Nonattorney Actions
      • Discipline Statistics
      • Look Up a Lawyer
    • En español
  • About Us
    • Our Mission
      • Protecting the Public
        • Regulation Overview
        • Public Comment
          • Public Comment Guidelines
          • Public Comment Archives
            • 2022 Public Comment
            • 2021 Public Comment
            • 2020 Public Comment
            • 2019 Public Comment
            • 2018 Public Comment
            • 2017 Public Comment
              • 2017-12
            • 2016 Public Comment
            • 2015 Public Comment
            • 2014 Public Comment
            • 2013 Public Comment
            • 2012 Public Comment
            • 2011 Public Comment
            • 2010 Public Comment
        • Reports
        • Public Records
      • Promoting Justice in California
      • Promoting Diversity and Inclusion
    • Who We Are
      • Board of Trustees
        • Roster
        • Meetings
        • Audit Commitee
          • Roster
        • Board Executive Committee
          • Roster
        • Finance Committee
          • Roster
        • Regulation and Discipline Committee
          • Roster
        • Public Comment Guidelines
        • Supreme Court Appointments
        • Board Task Forces
      • Committees
        • Meetings
        • Ad Hoc Commission on the Discipline System
          • Roster
        • Blue Ribbon Commission
          • Resources
          • Roster
        • California Board of Legal Specialization
        • California Paraprofessional Program Working Group
          • Roster
          • FAQ
        • Client Security Fund Commission
          • Roster
        • Closing the Justice Gap Working Group
          • Roster
        • Committee of Bar Examiners
          • Committee of State Bar Accredited and Registered Schools
            • Roster
          • Law School Council
            • Roster
        • Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct
        • Committee on Special Discipline Case Audit
          • Roster
        • Council on Access and Fairness
          • Roster
        • Judicial Nominees Evaluation
          • Background
          • Appointments
          • Review Committee of the Commission on Judicial Nominees Evaluation
          • Roster
          • FAQ
          • JNE Demographics Reports
        • Lawyer Assistance Program Oversight Committee
          • Roster
        • Legal Services Trust Fund Commission
          • Roster
        • Privacy Law Group
      • Archived Committees
      • Staff
      • State Bar Holidays
    • News
      • Fact Sheets
      • Reports
      • Multimedia
      • Public Meetings Calendar
      • California Bar Journal Archive
    • Careers
      • Job Listings
      • Benefits
      • Salary
    • Business Opportunities
      • Previous Opportunities
  • Attorneys
    • For Attorneys
      • About Your State Bar Profile
        • Fees & Payment
          • Agency Billing
          • Annual Fees FAQs
          • Voluntary Contributions
          • Fees and Charges
        • Status Changes
        • Address Change
        • Reporting Requirements
        • Certificate of Standing
      • Fingerprinting Rule Requirements
        • For In-State Attorneys
        • For Out-of-State Attorneys
        • For Out-of-Country Attorneys
          • Out-of-Country Deadline Extension Request
        • Multijurisdictional Practitioner
        • FAQ
        • Penalty Schedule
        • Limited Accommodations
        • Glossary
      • Lawyer Assistance Program
        • Voluntary LAP for Attorneys
        • Voluntary LAP for Law Students and Applicants
        • Monitored LAP
        • LAP Resources
        • LAP FAQ
      • Mandatory Fee Arbitration
        • Approved Programs
        • Forms & Resources
        • Arbitration Advisories
      • Opening and Managing Law Office
        • Insurance Programs
        • Limited Liability Partnerships
          • Forms
          • Rules
        • Law Corporations Program
          • Forms
          • Rules
        • Revoking Law Corporation
      • For Judges
      • FAQ
    • MCLE & CLE
      • Requirements
        • Types of MCLE Credit
        • Proportional Requirement
        • MCLE Recordkeeping
        • Attorney Exemptions
        • Attorney Exemptions FAQ
        • Approved Jurisdictions
        • Education Approval
          • Evaluate Credit
          • MCLE Credit Request
        • New Admittees
        • Inactive or Not Eligible Status
        • Out-of-State Residents
        • Good Cause Modification
      • Compliance
        • Who Must Report Compliance
        • Compliance Groups
        • Audit FAQ
      • New Attorney Training Program
      • E-Learning Portal
      • MCLE Providers
        • Provider Search
        • Single Activity Providers
        • Multiple Activity Providers
        • Provider Record Keeping
        • Qualifying Activities
        • ADA
      • MCLE Self-Study
        • MCLE Self-Study FAQs
      • CLE
        • Online CLE
        • CLE Self-Study
      • Rules
        • Rules Specific MCLE Credits
      • FAQ
    • Conduct & Discipline
      • Lawyer Regulation
      • Self-Reporting FAQ
      • State Bar Court
      • Client Trust Accounting & IOLTA
        • Guidelines
        • Client Trust Accounting Handbook
        • Client Trust Accounting Resources
        • Update Form
        • IOLTA-Eligible Banks
        • Interest Rates
        • FAQ
      • Rules
        • Rules of the State Bar
          • Title 1 Global Provisions
          • Title 2 Rights and Responsibilities of Licensees
          • Title 3 Programs and Services
          • Title 4 Admissions and Educational Standards
          • Title 5 Discipline
          • Title 6 Governance
          • Title 7 Miscellaneous
          • Appendixes
          • New and Amended Rules
        • Rules of Professional Conduct
          • Current Rules
            • Chapter 1. Lawyer-Client Relationship
            • Chapter 2. Counselor
            • Chapter 3. Advocate
            • Chapter 4. Transactions with Persons Other than Clients
            • Chapter 5. Law Firms and Associations
            • Chapter 6. Public Service
            • Chapter 7. Information About Legal Services
            • Chapter 8. Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession
          • Previous Rules
        • Selected Legal Authority
          • Constitution Excerpts
          • The State Bar Act
          • California Rules of Court
          • Statutes
      • Ethics
        • Hotline
        • Opinions
          • 2009-176 to Present
          • 1998-152 to 2008-175
          • 1992-126 to 1997-151
          • 1988-96 to 1991-125
          • 1984-76 to 1987-95
          • 1979-48 to 1983-75
          • 1971-24 to 1977-47
          • 1965-1 to 1970-23
        • Rules Spotlight Videos
        • Ethics Schools
          • Class Schedule
          • Ethics School FAQ
        • Ethics & Technology Resources
          • Ethics Opinions Related to Technology
          • Ethics Articles on Technology
          • Online Participatory MCLE Programs
          • Online Communication
          • Electronic Files
          • Law Firm Websites
          • Social Media
          • Internet/Email Scams
          • Miscellaneous
        • Senior Lawyers Resources
          • Rules
          • Opinions
          • Publications
            • Wellness Guide
          • Articles
          • MCLE
          • Links
          • Closing a Law Practice
          • Contact Us
          • Attorney Surrogacy
        • ADA Claims Information
        • Judicial Ethics
        • Attorney Civility and Professionalism
        • Publications
          • Ethics News
          • Hotliner Articles
            • Archives
          • Pub 250
          • Compendium on Professional Responsibility Index
        • Committees
          • COPRAC
            • Education
              • Ethics Symposium
            • Opinion Requests
            • Rules
            • Roster
          • Rules Revision
            • Rules Commission 2017
              • Summaries
              • Proposed Rules
              • Roster
            • Rules Commission 2014
              • Action Summaries
              • Meetings
              • Roster
    • Ethics
    • Legal Specialization
      • About Certified Specialization
      • Becoming a Certified Specialist
        • Exam Information
          • Exam Preparation Information
          • Laptop Computers
          • Testing Accommodations
      • Current Certified Specialists
      • Legal Specialty Areas
      • Specialist Search
      • MCLE Requirements for Certified Specialists
      • Education Providers
      • Governance
        • Board of Legal Specialization
          • Roster
      • Rules & Standards
        • Advertising
      • FAQ
    • Volunteer
      • Special Master
        • FAQ
        • Rules
        • List
  • Admissions
    • Requirements
      • Registration
      • Education
        • Pre-Legal Education
          • College Equivalency Education
        • Legal Education
          • Fixed Facility
          • Correspondence or Distance Learning
          • Law Office or Judge's Chamber
          • Foreign Education
            • Foreign Law Degree
      • Social Security Exemption
      • Attorney Applicants
    • Examinations
      • Dates and Deadlines
      • Safelisting Tips for Email
      • California Bar Examination
        • July 2022 California Bar Exam
        • Laptops for Bar Exam
        • July 2022 Bar Exam FAQs
        • Instructions for Essay Questions and Performance Test
        • Testing Centers
        • California Bar Examination Scope
        • Exam Results
          • Bar Exam Pass List
        • Past Exams
        • Grading
        • Scaling
        • Refund of Fees Policy
        • Virtual Oath Packet
        • Attorney's Oath
      • First-Year Law Students' Examination
        • June 2022 First-Year Exam
        • Laptops for First-Year Exam
        • Exam Results
        • First-Year Exam Grading and Scope
      • Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination
      • Requesting Testing Accommodations
      • Exam Administration
        • Becoming a Grader
        • Becoming a Proctor
    • Moral Character
      • Moral Character Statement
      • Governing Law
      • Process
      • Factors and Conduct
      • Further Investigation and Informal Conferences
      • Guidelines
    • Special Admissions
      • Multijurisdictional Practice (MJP) Program
        • MJP Program Requirements and Process
        • MJP Program Types
      • Pro Hac Vice
      • Out-of-State Attorney Arbitration Counsel (OSAAC)
      • Foreign Legal Consultants (FLC)
        • FAQ
        • Foreign Legal Consultants List
      • Practical Training of Law Students
      • Provisionally Licensed Lawyers
        • Search
    • Law School Regulation
      • Law Schools
      • Committee of Bar Examiners Meetings
        • Minutes
        • Minutes Archive
        • Roster
      • Exam Statistics
  • Access to Justice
    • Initiatives
      • California Justice Gap Study
        • Justice Gap Study Survey Data
        • California Law Student Survey Data
      • Publications
      • Leadership Banks
    • Pro Bono
      • Pro Bono Directory
        • Central Coast and Eastern Sierra
        • Central Valley Area
        • Los Angeles Area
        • Sacramento and Northern California
        • San Diego and Imperial Valley
        • San Francisco Area
        • Statewide
      • Pro Bono Practice Program
      • Volunteer After a Disaster
      • Volunteer Opportunities to Assist Veterans and Service Members
      • FAQ
    • Grants
      • Legal Aid Funding
      • 2022 Grant Recipients
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Lawyer Referral Services
    • Financial Institutions
      • IOLTA-Eligible Financial Institutions
  • 2019 Public Comment
Seal of The State Bar of California The State Bar of California

Proposed State Bar Rule of Procedure Setting Forth Guidelines for the Imposition and Collection of Monetary Sanctions

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Share with Email

The State Bar seeks public comment regarding a proposed State Bar Rule of Procedure 5.137 setting forth guidelines for the imposition and collection of monetary sanctions in State Bar disciplinary proceedings

Deadline: October 25, 2019

Background

The State Bar is seeking public comment on a redrafted proposed rule setting forth guidelines for the imposition and collection of sanctions to be ordered by the California Supreme Court when imposing suspension or disbarment of an attorney. A prior version of proposed rule 5.137 was submitted to the California Supreme Court for approval. After receiving comments from the California Supreme Court, staff worked closely with State Bar Court, to redraft the proposed rule.

Discussion

A.         Definition of “Violation”

Subsections (A), (C) and (D) of proposed rule 5.137 largely track the statutory language of Business & Professions Code section 6086.13 with some important additions. First, Business & Professions Code section 6086.13 subdivision (a) does not specify whether the $50,000 maximum for monetary sanctions is per disciplinary order or per individual respondent. Moreover, the statute does not define the term “violation.” Without a definition, “violation” could be interpreted as applying to either an individual count charged against a respondent in a complaint or to each transaction described within a count.

Proposed rule 5.137 clarifies that the maximum $50,000 referred to in the statute is per disciplinary order. Further, subsection (b) defines to the term “violation” to mean “each count (including its subparts) contained in a Notice of Disciplinary Charges for which the State Bar Court has found the licensee culpable, or each violation of a rule or statute the attorney admits to have violated in a stipulation.”  This definition was chosen to make clear that “violation” means a violation of The State Bar Act or Rules of Professional Conduct.  The Office of Trial Counsel charges one violation per count contained in a Notice of Disciplinary Charges.  Similarly,  with respect to stipulations, each “conclusion of law” being stipulated to is an independent violation of the State Bar Act or Rules of Professional Conduct.

At its meeting on September 19, 2019, the Board of Trustees’ Regulation and Discipline Committee considered these three proposed amendments and authorized a 60-day public comment period.

B.         Guidelines for Imposition of Monetary Sanctions

Subsection (E) sets forth the specific guidelines for the imposition and collection of monetary sanctions. This subsection provides State Bar Court broad discretion in determining the amount of monetary sanctions depending on the specific facts and circumstances of the discipline case. While the proposed rule has suggested sanctions ranges per order based on the nature of the discipline, it also specifies that “the State Bar Court may, in its discretion, deviate from the ranges set forth in this subsection to a maximum of $5,000 for each violation, and $50,000 for each disciplinary order.” (Proposed rule 5.137(E)(3).) Deviations should be reasonably based on the facts and circumstances for each case. Id. 

For example, for a disbarment case with five serious misconduct violations, State Bar Court may determine it is appropriate to recommend $25,000 in monetary sanctions total ($5,000 per violation). This amount is over the suggested guideline range of $5,000 per disbarment order, but within the $50,000 maximum per disciplinary ordered authorized by Business & Professions Code section 6086.13 subdivision (a).

The proposed rule further provides that “if the same conduct is encompassed by two or more separate violations, the Court generally should not impose more than one monetary sanction for that conduct. Instead, the Court should consider the most serious applicable violation for that conduct.” (Proposed rule 5.137(E)(3)(b).) This is analogous to California Penal Code section 654 which provides that the same punishable act cannot be punished under more than one provision of law. This language was added because there may be one disciplinary order containing multiple violations for the same conduct. In such cases, State Bar Court should consider the most serious violation when determining the sanctions amount, rather than imposing two separate sanctions per violation.

C.         Waivers, Payment Plan and Extensions of Time for Payment

Subsection (E)(4)-(5) specifies how monetary sanctions may be waived, in whole or in part, or the time for payment extended for specified good cause or in the interests of justice.  Specifically, subsection (E)(4) provides that the State Bar Court may use its discretion to waive costs or extend time to pay based on “on a finding of financial hardship, special circumstances, whether a licensee’s ability to pay criminal or civil judgments arising out of the discipline case is adversely affected, for good cause, or in the interests of justice.”

Subsection (E)(5) permits the licensee and the Office of Trial Counsel to stipulate to a waiver, payment plan and/or an extension of time for payment which must be approved by State Bar Court. Subsection (E)(6) provides a way for the licensee to affirmatively seek such relief in State Bar Court, following the procedures set forth in the State Bar Rules (currently, rule 5.130).

D.         Payment In Full Must Be Made Prior to Reinstatement

Subsection (F) specifies that monetary sanctions must be paid in full as a condition of reinstatement or return to active status, unless time for payment is extended. This ensures that monetary sanctions are treated the same as all other payment imposed as part of a disciplinary order by the California Supreme.  (see Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6140.5 [payment of client security fund reimbursement is a condition of continued practice and/or reinstatement]; Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6140.7 [unless time for payment is extended, disciplinary costs shall be paid as a condition of reinstatement or return to active membership].)

Lastly, subsection (G) states that imposed monetary sanctions are enforceable as a money judgment. This assures that the State Bar is able to undertake appropriate collection activities necessary to enforce its legal rights to all court ordered payments.

Proposal

This proposal, if adopted, would add a new rule that would require the State Bar Court to consider whether a respondent recommended to be suspended or disbarred, or who has resigned with charges pending, should be ordered to pay monetary sanctions as part of a disciplinary recommendation to the California Supreme Court. The rule sets forth criteria for the imposition and collection of these sanctions.

Any fiscal/personnel impact

If adopted, the proposed rule may provide additional funding to the State Bar Client Security Fund. (Business and Professions Code section 6054(a).)

The proposed rule may necessitate additional resources in OCTC and State Bar Court in order to assess monetary sanctions recommendations, handle respondent’s challenges to sanctions, and evaluate respondent’s requests for sanctions’ waivers, reductions, or payment plans.

Background material
  • Board Agenda Item
Source

Regulation and Discipline Committee

Deadline

October 25, 2019

Direct comments to

Suzanne Grandt
Office of General Counsel
180 Howard Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
Phone: 415-538-2388
Email: suzanne.grandt@calbar.ca.gov

Please reference the specific item in your comments.

Bar Seal
Protecting the public & enhancing the administration of justice.
  • Public
  • About Us
  • Attorneys
  • Admissions
  • Access to Justice
  • News
  • Forms
  • Careers
  • Staff Log in
  • San Francisco (Main Office)
    180 Howard St.
    San Francisco, CA 94105
    415-538-2000
  • Los Angeles
    845 S. Figueroa St.
    Los Angeles, CA 90017
    213-765-1000
Copyright © 2022 The State Bar of California
  • FAQ
  • User Policies
  • Contact
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn